betterlobsterlaw.com
Frequently Asked Questions - Lobster
 
Home Our Plan Facts & Figures News & Opinion FAQ Support About Us
Q: How much lobster is caught as bycatch?

A: Over the last 25 years, the various New England bycatch fisheries have harvested about 2% of the total lobster catch.  It takes a about a year for the bycatch fisheries to harvest as many lobsters as the directed trap fishery harvests each week.

Top

Q: How long have lobsters been caught as bycatch in New England?

A: There has always been lobster bycatch in the groundfish fishery. 

55 Years of Trap & Bycatch Harvests

Top

Q: What other Northeast states allow lobster to be landed as bycatch?

A: All of them.  Use the table below to view state-by-state regulations.  Each link will open a new browser window to the state's actual online regulations; scroll to the referenced section to read the state's law.

State Scroll to...
New Hampshire Page 24
Massachusetts Section 6.26
Rhode Island Page 31
Connecticut Page 12
New York Section 7
New Jersey Page 3

Top

Q: What do lobstermen elsewhere say about bycatch lobster landings?

A: In the fall of 2006, the federal agency responsible for managing lobsters solicited public comment on reducing or even eliminating bycatch lobster landings in all states.  All but Maine opposed any change to existing federal law.

 

Summary of public hearing comments on proposal
to change federal lobster bycatch law

       

State

FAVOR existing
federal bycatch law

OPPOSE bycatch

No comments received

 

 

 

 

Maine

 

 

 

New Hampshire

 

 

Massachusetts

 

 

Rhode Island

 

 

Connecticut

 

 

New York

 

 

 
 

Written recommendations from New England lobstermen's organizations on proposal to change federal lobster bycatch law

 

Organization

FAVOR existing
federal bycatch law

OPPOSE bycatch

 

 

 

Maine Offshore Lobstermen’s Assoc.

 

  

Atlantic Offshore Lobstermen’s Assoc.

 
Massachusetts Lobstermen’s Assoc.

 
Rhode Island Lobstermen’s Assoc.

 
     
 

Summary of all written comments on proposal
to change federal lobster bycatch law
 

 

     

Top

Q: Would changing Maine's law hurt Maine's 'broodstock' lobster population?

A: No for two reasons.

First, scientists consider the offshore lobster stock located in Area 3 to be a largely independent population from the inshore stock.  Area 3 lobsters are not believed to significantly contribute lobster larvae to Maine's inshore lobster stock

However, our proposal will likely help help the offshore Area 3 population.  Here's how:

Maine has two laws to protect  "broodstock" lobsters (large females that are known to reproduce).  The first is a requirement that a lobster carrying eggs (a "pregnant" lobster) be permanently marked with a "V-notch" (a small notch in a tail flipper), and returned to the sea.  From then on, the lobster cannot be harvested. 

The second law requires that all lobsters - male and female alike - whose body length is greater than 5 inches are always returned to the sea.  These are known as "oversized" lobsters, and are what the Maine lobster industry considers to be a 'broodstock' which contributes to lobster reproduction.

Currently, groundfish vessels which fish in Area 3 and land in Massachusetts are not required to return oversized lobsters to the sea.  Under our proposal, those vessels which returned to Maine would be.  This would mirror the broodstock conservation requirement of the Maine inshore lobster fishery. 

And once Maine's groundfish fleet is presented a vested interest in the health of the resource, it will contribute to V-notching oversize female lobsters - thus ensuring they cannot be landed in Massachusetts by another vessel fishing nearby.

In summary, any vessel fishing in Area 3 that chose to land its fish and bycatch lobsters in Maine, rather than in Massachusetts, would be contributing to the preservation of the offshore broodstock lobster population.

Top

Q: Will allowing bycatch landings in Maine mean that lobsters would be damaged by fishing gear?

A: No.  For the most part, these lobsters are already being harvested by trawl or gillnet gear.  The only difference is that Maine fishermen have to discard the lobsters.  Fishermen from other states can keep them.  And federal fishery observations suggest that damage from fishing gear is minor.  More...

Top

Q: Do lobsters harvested in the wintertime freeze?

A: No. Trawl, gillnet, and trap vessels alike all carry seawater tanks on board.  Lobsters are quickly placed in the tank so that they are not exposed to subfreezing air temperatures.  As with groundfishing, many lobster boats fish year-round, throughout the coldest winter months.

Top

Q: Will allowing bycatch lobster landings in Maine depress lobster prices?

A: No. It will have virtually no impact.  Each year, Maine lobster dealers import about $50 million of live lobster from Canada.  This source of supply has a far greater impact on the market than the approximately $3 million of lobster our proposal would produce.

Top

Q: Would fishermen have to sell bycatch lobsters to a specific buyer, such as the Portland Fish Exchange?

A: No. As with groundfish and trapped lobsters, fishermen would be free to sell  bycatch lobsters to any licensed dealer.

Top